Medicare Advantage Plans New York City 2025

Choosing the right Medicare Advantage plan in New York City can be daunting. If you need clarity on Medicare Advantage Plans New York City, plan types, costs, and the enrollment process, our guide sheds light on the precise options available to you, their benefits, and how to navigate the selection for your healthcare needs.


Key Takeaways



Compare Plans in One Step!

Enter Zip Code



Understanding Medicare Advantage Plans in New York City


Medicare Advantage Plans New York City 2025, Understanding Medicare Advantage Plans in New York City


Medicare Advantage Plans, also known as Medicare Part C, are an excellent alternative to the Original Medicare, providing all the benefits of Parts A (hospital insurance) and B (medical insurance), and often Part D (prescription drug coverage).

These plans are offered by Medicare-approved private insurance companies, which contract with the federal government to provide Medicare benefits.

However, while all New York-based Medicare Advantage plans must cover the Original Medicare benefits, private Medicare plans have the discretion to set their own co-pays and service coverage rules.

This means that the plans are tailored to individual needs and are available depending on where the beneficiary lives within New York City.


Types of Medicare Advantage Plans

When exploring Medicare Advantage Plans in New York City, you’ll encounter several types, each with varying degrees of flexibility, provider networks, and costs. These types include:

  • Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs)


  • Preferred Provider Organizations (PPO)


  • Private Fee-for-Service (PFFS)


  • Special Needs Plans (SNP)


HMO plans, for instance, usually mandate that members use network providers and designate a primary care physician for referrals to specialists. PPO plans, on the other hand, provide greater flexibility, allowing members to see both in-network and out-of-network providers without needing to select a primary care physician or obtain specialist referrals.

PFFS plans offer the most flexibility, allowing you to see any doctor or provider that agrees to the plan’s terms, with no requirements for a primary care physician or specialist referrals.

Notably, some PFFS Medicare Advantage Plans may include prescription drug coverage, but if they don’t, members must enroll in a separate Medicare drug plan to receive this coverage.


Enrollment Periods and Eligibility

Eligibility for Medicare Advantage Plans in NYC requires enrollment in Medicare Parts A and B, and there are specific enrollment periods for seniors and those with qualifying disabilities. From January 1 to March 31 each year, the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment period offers the chance to switch plans.

But if you’re new to Medicare, you can sign up for Medicare Advantage plans three months before your 65th birthday month and three months after.

The Medicare Annual Enrollment Period goes from October 15 through December 7 each year, during which changes to Medicare Advantage plans can be made. To be eligible for Medicare Advantage plans in New York City, individuals must be 65 or older or have certain disabilities or End-Stage Renal Disease.

Remember, individuals with permanent disabilities become eligible after a two-year waiting period of receiving Social Security Disability Insurance, barring conditions like End-Stage Renal Disease or ALS.

In addition, those receiving Social Security or Railroad Retirement Board benefits who turn 65 or have been receiving disability benefits for 24 months are automatically enrolled in Medicare.

Comparing Top Providers of Medicare Advantage Plans in NYC


Medicare Advantage Plans New York City 2025,Comparing Top Providers of Medicare Advantage Plans in NYC


With several providers offering Medicare Advantage Plans in NYC, comparing them can seem daunting. There’s no need for concern, we’ll break it down for you.

Here are some of the best Medicare Advantage plans in New York:

  • Independent Health: 5-star CMS rating


  • CDPHP Medicare Advantage: 4.5-star CMS rating


  • Excellus BlueCross BlueShield: 4.5-star CMS rating


  • MVP Health Care: 4.5-star CMS rating


There are several other providers as well, including Centers Plan for Healthy Living, Elderplan, EmblemHealth, Healthfirst Medicare Plan, Independent Health, MediGold, MetroPlus Health Plan, VillageCareMAX, and VNS Health Medicare. Each of these providers offers unique plans with varying benefits.

For instance, the 65 Plus Plan (HMO) provides additional benefits such as $0 monthly plan premium and low or no copays for prescription drugs.


Prominent Providers

In the sea of Medicare Advantage plan providers in New York City, some have managed to stand out based on their CMS Star Ratings, which reflect member experience and overall plan quality. Blue Cross Blue Shield, for example, is well-known for its strong local support and has a CMS Star Rating of 3.86 out of 5.

Humana, with a CMS Star Rating of 4.34 out of 5, is lauded for high member satisfaction and the availability of low-cost plans.

UnitedHealthcare, recognized for the size of its network, boasts a CMS Star Rating of 3.87 out of 5. Aetna’s Medicare Advantage plans are known for their extra perks and have a CMS Star Rating of 3.98 out of 5.

A few providers have managed to achieve even higher CMS Star Ratings. Independent Health offers a 5-star rated Medicare Advantage plan, while CDPHP Medicare Advantage, Excellus BlueCross BlueShield, and MVP Health Care offer plans rated 4.5 stars by CMS.

Healthfirst stands out by integrating Medicare and Medicaid benefits with added long-term care. The plan premium is $0 per month and includes prescription drug coverage, an OTC Plus card, and no copays.

It also offers these additional benefits. These CMS Star Ratings and additional plan benefits provided by these providers are critical factors for individuals considering Medicare Advantage plans in New York City.


Plan Availability by ZIP Code

One crucial aspect to consider when selecting a Medicare Advantage Plan in NYC is the plan’s availability in your specific ZIP code. In 2024, the city offered 280 Medicare Advantage plans, a slight reduction from the 288 plans available in 2023.

You can find out which Medicare Advantage plans are available to you by entering your specific ZIP code into a plan finder tool. This will help you access the options that are tailored to your area.

Bear in mind that the availability of New York Medicare Advantage plans is not uniform as not all the 28 providers offer plans throughout the city. Plan availability and options within Medicare Advantage plans in New York may differ considerably by county, affecting the range of benefits individuals can receive.

Compare plans and enroll online



Speak with a licensed insurance agent

TTY 711

Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm ET

compare medicare advantage plans

Additional Benefits and Features of NYC Medicare Advantage Plans


Medicare Advantage Plans New York City 2025, Additional Benefits and Features of NYC Medicare Advantage Plans


In addition to the standard coverage, NYC Medicare Advantage Plans may include additional perks that make them even more appealing. Some of these additional perks may include:

  • Fitness programs


  • Health and wellness services


  • SilverSneakers fitness program


  • 24/7 access to care


For example, Healthfirst Medicare Advantage plans include the SilverSneakers fitness program and provide 24/7 access to care.

Further enhancing their value, these plans may also include coverage for over-the-counter drugs and transportation to doctor visits. Many Medicare Advantage plans offer additional benefits such as dental, hearing, and vision care, which are not covered by Original Medicare.


Prescription Drug Coverage

Most Medicare Advantage plans in New York City include Part D prescription drug coverage, a crucial factor for many individuals. Enrollees typically pay an additional monthly premium for their Medicare Advantage Plan which includes prescription drug coverage over the standard Part B premium.

In the case of HMO and PPO plan members, if their plan does not provide drug coverage, they need to switch plans.

Understanding the nuances of your prescription drug coverage, such as medication tiers and any coverage guidelines, is essential.

For those eligible, the ‘Extra Help’ program may assist with prescription drug costs. Additionally, the Elderly Pharmaceutical Insurance Coverage (EPIC) program by the New York State Department of Health offers prescription assistance to older residents lacking adequate coverage and not on Medicaid.


Dental and Vision Care


Medicare Advantage Plans New York City 2025


Beyond the basic coverage, some Medicare Advantage plans take a step further to include dental and vision care. Original Medicare does not generally include dental exams, procedures, or supplies, and is limited in vision care.

It only covers medically necessary services, which excludes most eye exams, eyeglasses, or related vision services.

However, Medicare Advantage plans may include additional coverage for dental and vision health items, expanding beyond the basic coverage provided by Original Medicare. However, keep in mind that the scope and cost of dental and vision coverage can vary greatly among Medicare Advantage plans.


Wellness Programs and Gym Memberships

The focus on wellness and preventive care is a significant trend in healthcare, and Medicare Advantage Plans are no exception. Some Medicare Advantage Plans in New York City include wellness benefits such as access to fitness centers and online exercise classes.

Programs like SilverSneakers offer gym membership discounts and are often partnered with Medicare Advantage plans to promote well-being among seniors. However, the details of wellness programs and gym membership benefits might differ among plans.

Hence, beneficiaries should directly liaise with their Medicare Advantage Plan to comprehend the specifics of their wellness programs and gym membership benefits.

Navigating Special Needs Plans (SNPs) in NYC


Medicare Advantage Plans New York City 2025, Navigating Special Needs Plans (SNPs) in NYC


Healthcare needs can vary significantly from person to person, and some individuals may require more specialized care.

For such individuals, Special Needs Plans (SNPs) in New York City are designed to cater to beneficiaries with needs such as chronic illness, those requiring institutional care, or individuals with dual Medicare and Medicaid eligibility.

In NYC, available SNPs include Chronic-Condition Special Needs Plans (C-SNPs) for those with severe or disabling chronic conditions, and Institutional Special Needs Plans (I-SNPs) for individuals living in institutions or requiring nursing home-level care.

As part of their benefits, all Special Needs Plans (SNPs) are required to provide Medicare prescription drug coverage (Part D).


Dual Special Needs Plans (D-SNPs)

Dual Special Needs Plans (D-SNPs) in NYC are particularly notable. These plans are tailored to dual-eligible beneficiaries to provide integrated care, encompassing doctor visits, hospital care, and prescription medication.

Programs like the IB-Dual program, replacing Medicaid Advantage, offer comprehensive Medicaid services without the need for long-term support for dual-eligible beneficiaries. Plus, care coordination is a significant benefit of D-SNPs, made seamless by the Default Enrollment process that automatically transitions eligible Medicaid members to their health plan’s D-SNP upon Medicare eligibility.

Health first’s Special Needs Plan and Connection Plan (HMO D-SNP) are examples of D-SNPs that provide members with:

  • No premium costs


  • $0 for covered prescription drugs


  • An OTC Plus card


  • Minimal to no copays.

Choosing the Right Medicare Advantage Plan in NYC


Medicare Advantage Plans New York City 2025, Choosing the Right Medicare Advantage Plan in NYC


With the wide array of Medicare Advantage Plans and providers available in NYC, choosing the right one can be a daunting task. However, the choice of a Medicare Advantage plan should be tailored to the individual’s healthcare needs.

The inclination for provider flexibility and assurance that certain doctors accept the plan are pivotal factors in choosing the appropriate Medicare Advantage Plan.


Assessing Costs and Coverage

One key step in selecting a Medicare Advantage Plan is comprehending the cost spectrum associated with different plans, encompassing the following:

  • Premium


  • Deductibles


  • Copays


  • Coinsurance


In 2024, the average monthly premium for Medicare Advantage plans in New York City was $30.79, up from $26.15 in 2023, with plans available that have a $0 premium.

Keep in mind that overall costs of health insurance can vary based on the chosen plan and individual healthcare needs.

For instance, HMO plans may provide lower out-of-pocket costs compared to PFFS plans, partly because PFFS plans can lead to balance billing, where providers are allowed to charge up to 15% more than what the plan reimburses for their services.

Also, the standard Part B premium in 2024 is $174.70, and it may be higher for individuals based on income, influencing the overall cost of Medicare coverage for enrollees.


Evaluating Provider Networks

Another crucial aspect to consider when selecting a Medicare Advantage Plan is the provider network and its associated Medicare contract. Medicare Advantage networks on average include less than half of all physicians in a county, and network size among Medicare Advantage plans can vary significantly, even within the same county.

Access to specialists is often more restricted in Medicare Advantage plans, with psychiatrists being notably less accessible. Beneficiaries may face significant costs if they accidentally use out-of-network services due to the complexity of comparing provider networks.

Hence, when choosing a Medicare Advantage plan, it’s crucial to confirm that the chosen medical providers are part of the plan’s network.

Resources for New Yorkers Seeking Medicare Assistance

After all that’s been said, you might still need some help navigating the Medicare landscape in NYC. The good news is there are numerous resources available for New Yorkers seeking Medicare assistance. From state and federal websites to local organizations, you’re not alone in this journey.


State and Federal Resources

State and federal resources can be invaluable in helping you understand and select the right Medicare Advantage Plan. New York City residents can call 800-MEDICARE or visit the federal Medicare website for information on Medicare Advantage plans.

The Medicare Savings Program (MSP) in New York City helps eligible individuals with the cost of Medicare premiums and cost-sharing requirements such as copays and deductibles.

For questions about quality of care, and to assist with Medicare appeals and billing issues, Medicare beneficiaries can contact Livanta at 1-866-815-5440.

Using’s plan finder tool, individuals can compare Medicare Advantage plans, check their availability, and view CMS ratings in their area.


Local Support Organizations

In addition to state and federal resources, New York City residents also have access to local support organizations for Medicare enrollment. These organizations provide free in-person assistance through the Facilitated Enrollment for the Aged, Disabled, and Blind Program to apply for Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans.


In conclusion, navigating the landscape of Medicare Advantage Plans in New York City can be complex, but with a clear understanding of your healthcare needs, the types of plans, their costs, and the provider networks, you can make an informed choice.

Remember, you’re not alone in this journey – state, federal, and local resources are there to guide you. So, take your time, do your research, and choose the plan that best suits your needs.


Frequently Asked Questions


→  Does New York have Medicare Advantage plans?

Yes, New York offers Medicare Advantage plans which cover Medicare Parts A and B, along with additional coverage such as prescription drugs, dental, vision, and hearing care. Keep in mind that not all plan types are available in each county.


  What is a Medicare Advantage Plan?

A Medicare Advantage Plan, also known as Medicare Part C, is an alternative to Original Medicare, offering benefits from Medicare-approved private insurance companies, and may include prescription drug coverage.


  How do I choose the right Medicare Advantage Plan in NYC?

To choose the right Medicare Advantage Plan in NYC, assess your healthcare needs, compare plan costs, and consider provider networks. Choose a plan that best fits your requirements.


 What is the average monthly premium for Medicare Advantage plans in NYC?

The average monthly premium for Medicare Advantage plans in New York City was $30.79 in 2024.

call today for help


 ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company

Find & Compare Plans Online 



Speak with a licensed insurance agent

TTY 711

Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Russell Noga
( Medicare Expert )

Russell Noga is the CEO of ZRN Health & Financial Services, and head content editor of several Medicare insurance online publications. He has over 15 years of experience as a licensed Medicare insurance broker helping Medicare beneficiaries learn about Medicare, Medicare Advantage Plans, Medigap insurance, and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans.