Medicare Advantage Plans NY 2025

The landscape of Medicare Advantage plans in New York is continuously evolving, with the year 2025 promising even more growth and innovation. As a Medicare beneficiary, it’s essential to stay informed of these changes to make the most of your healthcare coverage.

This comprehensive guide will take you through the expected developments in Medicare Advantage plans NY 2025, comparisons with Traditional Medicare, enrollment processes, maximizing benefits, and resources to help you choose the best plan for your needs.


Key Takeaways

  • By 2025, New York is expected to see an increase in Medicare Advantage plan enrollment and offerings.


  • Comparing Traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage Plans in NY can help individuals make the best decision for their healthcare coverage.


  • Resources such as online tools, local agencies, assistance programs and educational events are available to aid beneficiaries in selecting a suitable plan for their individual needs.


Compare Plans in One Step!

Enter Zip Code



Medicare Advantage Plans in New York 2025: What to Expect


Medicare Advantage Plans NY 2025, Medicare Advantage Plans in New York 2025: What to Expect


Approaching 2025, we anticipate continued growth in enrollment, diverse plan offerings, and possible changes in benefits and coverage for Medicare Advantage plans in New York.

The suggested policies aim to strengthen protections for beneficiaries and promote competition, enhancing access to behavioral health care providers and supplemental benefits.

Given that Medicare Advantage plans now cover more than half of all Medicare beneficiaries in the state, understanding the implications of this growth on healthcare coverage and its meaning for Medicare beneficiaries in New York becomes imperative.


Enrollment Growth and Market Share

Medicare Advantage enrollment rates have seen significant growth in recent years, with medicare advantage enrollees on the rise. Projections for 2025 indicate that these plans will compose half of the total Medicare enrollment, representing 35 million beneficiaries, up from 21.1 million in 2018.

Notably, enrollment in special needs plans alone has surged by 24% between 2022 and 2023.

UnitedHealthcare and Humana have the highest enrollment rates in Medicare Advantage plans, accounting for 47% of enrollment in 2023 nationwide. Beneficiaries in New York can expect more competition among insurance companies, leading to innovative plan offerings and additional benefits.


Plan Offerings and Innovations

By 2025, residents of New York can anticipate novel plan offerings and extra benefits from Medicare Advantage providers, thanks to the Medicare Modernization Act.

These include the extension of the Medicare Advantage Value-Based Insurance Design (VBID) Model for calendar years 2025 through 2030, which introduces modifications to align flexibilities for concurrent curative care and hospice with other CMS Innovation Center models.

The trend of innovation in the Medicare Advantage plan market in New York includes the entry of new insurers, growth of plan options, and introduction of new supplemental benefits. These innovative offerings aim to address the needs of the aging population and enhance the quality of care for enrollees.


Potential Changes in Benefits and Coverage

Policy adjustments and market competition may lead to changes in benefits and coverage.

As Medicare Advantage plans incur higher costs per beneficiary for the government and taxpayers compared to traditional Medicare, evaluating the effectiveness of the current Medicare payment methodology for Medicare Advantage becomes crucial for optimizing efficiency and controlling costs for beneficiaries and Medicare spending.

As Medicare Advantage plans develop, Medicare Advantage plan enrollees must keep ahead of policy changes, possible modifications to benefits, and the effects these changes could have on their healthcare coverage.


Comparing Traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage Plans in NY


Medicare Advantage Plans NY 2025, Comparing Traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage Plans in NY


Understanding the differences between Traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans in New York is fundamental for healthcare coverage.

We will analyze cost differences, benefit variations, and provider networks, equipping you with the necessary information for a well-informed decision about your healthcare coverage.

Comparing these aspects will offer an insightful understanding of the pros and cons of each plan type, empowering you to make the optimal choice for your personal needs and circumstances.


Cost Differences

Although Medicare Advantage plans may seem more cost-efficient due to their low or nonexistent monthly premiums compared to Traditional Medicare, these plans generally impose higher costs per beneficiary on the government and taxpayers.

The extra cost of Medicare Advantage results from the complexity of the established rate, permitting multiple adjustments and bonus payments.

On the other hand, Medicare Advantage plans may provide lower out-of-pocket costs and additional benefits such as dental, vision, and wellness coverage not included in Traditional Medicare.

It’s essential to weigh the costs and benefits of each type of plan, including other Medicare Advantage plans, to determine which best suits your needs.


Benefit Variations

Medicare Advantage plans in New York provide extra benefits absent in Traditional Medicare, including dental and vision coverage, transportation services, and prescription drug coverage. Choosing between Traditional Medicare and a Medicare Advantage plan, or among individual Medicare Advantage plans, can prove complex and challenging.

The practice of Medigap insurers being able to deny or set premiums based on individual health status in most states can be a huge disincentive for many people to switch to Traditional Medicare. This could have the effect of raising costs for those beneficiaries already using Medicare services.

It’s crucial to compare the benefits provided by each plan type to determine which best meets your healthcare needs.


Provider Networks and Access

In 2022, the average beneficiary had access to 39 plans, with the average Medicare beneficiary in 2023 having access to 43 Medicare Advantage plans, representing the highest number of options available to date.

While Medicare Advantage plans feature networks of doctors, health centers, hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, and other care providers, Traditional Medicare allows beneficiaries to access any doctor or provider that accepts Medicare.

Utilizing in-network providers in Medicare Advantage plans can reduce out-of-pocket costs, but may also limit access to care, compared to Traditional Medicare.

It is essential for individuals to consider their preferred providers and the network restrictions when selecting between the two options.


Compare plans and enroll online



Speak with a licensed insurance agent

TTY 711

Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm ET

compare medicare advantage plans

Navigating the Medicare Advantage Enrollment Process in NY


Medicare Advantage Plans NY 2025, Navigating the Medicare Advantage Enrollment Process in NY


Understanding the Initial Enrollment Period, Special Enrollment Periods, and Annual/Open Enrollment Periods is key to navigating the Medicare Advantage enrollment process in New York.

Each of these enrollment periods presents opportunities for beneficiaries to review their healthcare coverage options and modify their plans.

Being aware of these enrollment periods and understanding the eligibility criteria for each can help ensure that you select the best Medicare Advantage plan for your needs and circumstances.


Initial Enrollment Period

The Initial Enrollment Period for Medicare Advantage in New York begins three months prior to an individual’s 65th birthday month and concludes three months after it.

During this 7-month period, individuals can enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan for the first time.

If you fail to enroll in Medicare Advantage during the Initial Enrollment Period, you may be subject to a monthly late enrollment penalty for as long as you have Part B. It is essential to be aware of this enrollment period and act within the designated timeframe to avoid potential penalties.


Special Enrollment Periods

Special Enrollment Periods occur when specific life events or circumstances allow for plan changes. Examples of qualifying life events include relocation, loss of other health coverage, or qualification for Medicaid.

These periods typically span two months, during which individuals can join a Medicare Advantage Plan or make changes to their existing plan.

Understanding the criteria for Special Enrollment Periods and being aware of the available timeframes can help ensure that you make timely adjustments to your healthcare coverage in response to life changes.


Annual and Open Enrollment Periods

Annual and Open Enrollment Periods provide opportunities for beneficiaries to review and change their Medicare Advantage plans.

The Annual Enrollment Period for Medicare Advantage Plans in New York runs from October 15th to December 7th annually, while the Open Enrollment Period is from January 1st to March 31st annually.

During these enrollment periods, beneficiaries can make changes to their healthcare coverage, such as switching plans or changing coverage options. Staying informed about these enrollment periods can help ensure you have the best possible healthcare coverage for your needs.


Maximizing Your Medicare Advantage Plan Benefits in NY


Medicare Advantage Plans NY 2025, Maximizing Your Medicare Advantage Plan Benefits in NY


Optimal use of your Medicare Advantage plan benefits in NY involves utilizing in-network providers, leveraging supplemental benefits, and comprehending appeals and prior authorization processes.

Following these strategies can reduce your out-of-pocket expenses and enhance the value of your healthcare coverage.

Being proactive in utilizing the benefits and resources available to you through your Medicare Advantage plan can lead to improved health outcomes and greater satisfaction with your healthcare coverage, especially when taking full advantage of the Medicare Advantage program.


Utilizing In-Network Providers

Using in-network providers can help reduce out-of-pocket costs for beneficiaries through cost sharing. Medicare Advantage plans in New York have negotiated lower rates with the providers in their network, leading to lower co payments, coinsurance, and deductibles compared to using out-of-network providers.

To optimize the use of in-network providers with a Medicare Advantage Plan in New York, it’s essential to ensure network directory accuracy, fulfill network adequacy standards, and enhance provider quality and efficiency.

By utilizing in-network providers, you can maximize the benefits of your Medicare Advantage Plan and minimize your healthcare expenses.


Taking Advantage of Supplemental Benefits

Supplemental benefits, such as dental and vision coverage, can enhance overall healthcare coverage.

To maximize the supplemental benefits of your Medicare Advantage plan in NY, familiarize yourself with the available benefits, take advantage of preventive services, and utilize additional services offered by your plan.

By taking full advantage of the supplemental benefits offered by your Medicare Advantage plan, you can improve your overall healthcare experience and reduce out-of-pocket expenses.


Understanding Appeals and Prior Authorization Processes

Understanding the appeals and prior authorization processes can help beneficiaries access necessary care and services. The appeal process for a Medicare Advantage Plan in New York involves several levels, where you may continue to appeal if you are not satisfied with the decision made at each level.

By being informed about these processes and knowing your rights as a beneficiary, you can ensure that you receive the care and services you need while minimizing the financial burden associated with healthcare.


Resources for Choosing a Medicare Advantage Plan in NY

Medicare Advantage Plans NY 2025, Resources for Choosing a Medicare Advantage Plan in NY

Choosing the right Medicare Advantage plan in NY may be complicated, but you can make use of available resources to help make a well-informed decision. These resources encompass online tools and websites, local agencies and assistance programs, and educational events and seminars.

By utilizing these resources, you can gain valuable insights and information to help you choose the best Medicare Advantage plan for your unique needs and circumstances.


Online Tools and Websites

Online resources such as:

  •’s Plan Comparison Tool


  • The Medicare Plan Finder


  • NerdWallet


  • Forbes Health


  • US News




  • MedicareWire


can help beneficiaries compare plan options and find the best fit for their needs. These websites provide reviews of Medicare Advantage Plans in New York.

By utilizing these online tools and websites, you can better understand the various plan options available to you and make an informed decision about your health care coverage.


Local Agencies and Assistance Programs

Local agencies and assistance programs in New York can provide personalized guidance and support in selecting a Medicare Advantage plan. These agencies include Healthfirst, EmblemHealth, and Erie County Senior Services, which help with selecting Medicare Advantage Plans.

By working with these local agencies and assistance programs, you can receive valuable guidance in navigating the complex world of Medicare Advantage plans and finding the best fit for your healthcare needs, including Medicaid services and the Medicare program.


Educational Events and Seminars

Educational events and seminars offer opportunities for beneficiaries to learn more about Medicare Advantage plans and ask questions. These events typically address topics such as:

  • Understanding Medicare Advantage plans


  • Enrollment periods


  • Benefits and coverage options


  • Managing healthcare costs


By attending these events, you can gain valuable knowledge and insights to help you make informed decisions about your healthcare coverage.



In conclusion, Medicare Advantage plans in New York continue to evolve, offering innovative benefits and coverage options for beneficiaries.

As you navigate the world of Medicare Advantage, it’s essential to stay informed about the differences between Traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans, understand the enrollment process, and utilize available resources to make the best decision for your healthcare needs. By doing so, you can maximize your benefits, minimize your out-of-pocket expenses, and ensure a better healthcare experience.


Frequently Asked Questions


  Is Medicare Advantage plans going away?

Based on the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) announcement, Medicare Advantage and Medicare Prescription Drug Programs will not be going away in 2024.


→  Is Medicare premiums going down in 2024?

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has announced that the standard monthly Part B premium will be $174.70 in 2024, an increase of $9.80 from $164.90 in 2023.

The monthly Part A premium is decreasing by $1, but overall, Medicare premiums are going up in 2024.


  What is the projected Medicare Advantage enrollment in 2030?

By 2030, an estimated 37.5 million Americans will be enrolled in Medicare Advantage, a significant increase from the 24.2 million enrolled today.


  What are the CMS changes for 2024?

CMS has finalized a 3.37% reduction in the 2024 Medicare conversion factor from $33.8872 to $32.7442 and a 3.27% reduction in the anesthesia conversion factor from $21.1249 to $20.4349 for 2024.

Additionally, an add-on payment for HCPCS code G2211 will be implemented to better recognize the resource costs associated with evaluation and management visits for primary care and longitudinal care.


  What is the projected growth in Medicare Advantage enrollment in New York by 2025?

By 2025, Medicare Advantage enrollment in New York is projected to significantly increase, with plans accounting for half of total Medicare enrollment.


call today for help




 ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company

Find & Compare Plans Online 



Speak with a licensed insurance agent

TTY 711

Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Russell Noga
( Medicare Expert )

Russell Noga is the CEO of ZRN Health & Financial Services, and head content editor of several Medicare insurance online publications. He has over 15 years of experience as a licensed Medicare insurance broker helping Medicare beneficiaries learn about Medicare, Medicare Advantage Plans, Medigap insurance, and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans.