Understanding the Star Rating System

The star rating system, established by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), rates Medicare Advantage plans on a scale from 1 to 5 stars, with 5 stars representing the highest quality. These cms ratings assist beneficiaries in comparing the quality and performance of different plans. The criteria include:
- Preventive care
- Chronic condition management
- Customer service
- Member experience
A 5-star rating signifies exceptional quality and service, often leading to bonus payments for the plans. In Texas, top-rated plans include KelseyCare Advantage and UnitedHealthcare. These ratings can greatly assist in choosing a high-quality Medicare Advantage plan that suits your healthcare needs.
Top-Rated Medicare Advantage Plans in Texas
The star rating is a crucial quality indicator when selecting a Medicare Advantage plan. Plans with 4 stars or higher are typically top-tier options. These ratings reflect factors like patient satisfaction and care effectiveness. In Texas, top Medicare Advantage plans with high star ratings include KelseyCare Advantage and UnitedHealthcare.
UnitedHealthcare is a national leader in Medicare Advantage, known for high member satisfaction scores. For 2026, Texas offers 426 Medicare Advantage plans, an increase from previous years, providing numerous options for beneficiaries.
Approximately 75% of Medicare-eligible individuals in Texas have access to a $0-premium plan, making it easier to find a high-quality, affordable option.
Best 5-Star Plans
Devoted Health offers some of the top 5-star Medicare Advantage plans in Texas for 2026, and UnitedHealthcare also has a highly rated 5-star plan. These plans offer comprehensive coverage and high-quality service, reflected in their superior ratings. The CMS star rating system evaluates these plans on multiple criteria, ensuring top-notch care and customer satisfaction.
Opting for a 5-star plan like Devoted Health or UnitedHealthcare ensures exceptional care and extensive coverage. Known for their robust networks and extensive benefits, these plans are excellent choices for those seeking the best Medicare Advantage options.
High-Performing 4.5-Star Plans
High-performing 4.5-star Medicare Advantage plans in Texas include:
- Alignment Health Plan
- Humana
- KelseyCare Advantage
- Prominence
- UnitedHealthcare
Providers like Humana consistently demonstrate high performance, focusing on wellness offerings and enhanced drug coverage.
For instance, Humana emphasizes wellness programs and preventive care, making it a strong contender for comprehensive health benefits. These 4.5-star plans balance quality and affordability, ensuring excellent care without breaking the bank.
Notable 4-Star Plans
Notable 4-star Medicare Advantage plans in Texas are offered by Aetna and Wellcare. Aetna’s offerings include:
- Aetna Medicare Dual Care (HMO D-SNP)
- Aetna Medicare Eagle (PPO)
- Aetna Medicare Enhanced (PPO)
- Aetna Medicare Full
These plans offered provide various options, though not all plans have been reported to have issues with consistency and customer service in their ppo plan. Most plans have been designed to cater to different needs.
Wellcare’s Medicare Advantage plans focus on affordability and serving lower-income populations. These 4-star plans are viable options for those seeking solid coverage with a reasonable premium.
Key Considerations When Choosing a Medicare Advantage Plan
Selecting the right Medicare Advantage plan involves considering the following factors:
- Assess your coverage needs based on your health conditions and the services you’ll need throughout the year.
- Evaluate out-of-pocket costs, such as deductibles and copayments, to budget healthcare expenses.
- Consider the availability of supplemental benefits like wellness programs that can enhance your healthcare experience.
Star ratings are a helpful guide but just one aspect of the selection process. Other key considerations include prescription drug coverage, provider networks, and out-of-pocket costs. Understanding these factors ensures you choose a plan that best suits your healthcare needs and financial situation.
Prescription Drug Coverage

Many Medicare Advantage plans include Part D coverage, essential for managing prescription drug needs. The average monthly premium for these plans in Texas is projected to be around $4.35 for 2026, lower than in previous years.
It’s crucial to ensure your medications are covered under the plan. Many plans include this benefit, but checking specific drug coverage is important to avoid unexpected costs. This can significantly impact managing healthcare expenses effectively.
Provider Networks
When choosing a Medicare Advantage plan, ensure your preferred healthcare providers are in the plan’s network, including:
- Doctors
- Specialists
- Hospitals’ Medicare Advantage plans often include a network of healthcare providers, but care is generally limited to services within this network for non-emergencies.
Certain services may require prior authorization. If denied, patients may bear the full cost of the service. Checking the provider network beforehand prevents unexpected expenses and ensures continuity of care with your primary care provider to pay for necessary treatments.
Out-of-Pocket Costs
Out-of-pocket costs are a significant consideration when choosing a Medicare Advantage plan. For 2026, the average monthly premium for these plans in Texas is projected to be $4.35. These costs include deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance, all of which should be considered when budgeting.
Medicare Advantage plans have yearly caps on out-of-pocket expenses, ensuring beneficiaries don’t exceed a certain spending limit. Reaching this limit means no longer paying for covered services for the rest of the year. Understanding these caps and your potential healthcare needs helps in choosing a plan that minimizes out-of-pocket expenses.