Humana vs Aetna Medicare Advantage
Trying to decide between Humana vs Aetna Medicare Advantage? This guide will help you compare plan coverage, costs, provider networks, and customer satisfaction.
Key Takeaways
- Humana and Aetna offer extensive Medicare Advantage Plans across multiple states, with unique benefits such as Humana’s Part B Giveback and Aetna’s robust vision coverage.
- The choice between HMO and PPO plans significantly affects provider access, impacting healthcare costs and convenience, depending on individual healthcare needs.
- Customer satisfaction varies, with Aetna receiving high ratings in some areas but lower scores in others, while Humana’s performance emphasizes the importance of digital satisfaction and member experience.
Compare Plans In One Step!
Quick Overview of Humana and Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans
Humana and Aetna are two of the most prominent providers and insurers of Medicare Advantage Plans in the United States. Humana offers plans in 46 states and Washington, D.C., covering approximately 85% of U.S. counties.
This extensive reach ensures that most beneficiaries have access to Humana’s offerings. One of the unique benefits of Humana’s plans is the Part B Giveback, which reimburses part of the member’s Medicare Part B premiums, providing additional financial relief.
On the other hand, Aetna provides Medicare Advantage Plans accessible to 57 million beneficiaries across 43 states and Washington, D.C.
Despite this broad accessibility, there’s a trend among large providers, including Humana and Aetna, to reduce the number of counties they serve. This strategy aims to enhance profitability and focus on areas where they can deliver the most value.
When comparing Humana and Aetna, consider these trends and the specific benefits each provider offers. While both companies provide a range of plans, understanding their reach and unique features can help you determine which one aligns better with your healthcare needs.
Plan Coverage Differences
When comparing Medicare Advantage Plans, the differences in coverage can be significant. Humana’s plans, for instance, include comprehensive dental coverage, which can encompass both preventive and comprehensive services.
This means routine cleanings, exams, and even more extensive dental work could be covered, providing substantial value to those who prioritize dental health.
Aetna’s plans offer the following benefits:
- Robust vision coverage, which may include routine eye exams and discounts on eyewear
- Wellness programs
- Meal delivery services cater to the overall well-being of their members
These additional benefits can be a deciding factor for those looking for a holistic approach to healthcare with fewer options.
Both Humana and Aetna offer comprehensive prescription drug coverage as part of their Medicare Advantage Plans. However, the specific benefits and coverage details can vary, so a thorough analysis of each plan’s offerings is necessary to ensure it meets your needs.
Whether you prioritize dental, vision, wellness programs, or prescription drug coverage, understanding these differences will help you make an informed decision.
Pricing and Out-of-Pocket Costs
Knowing the pricing and out-of-pocket costs of Medicare Advantage Plans is vital for managing your healthcare expenses. In 2025, these plans have a maximum out-of-pocket limit of $9,350 for in-network care and $14,000 for combined in-network and out-of-network services. This cap offers significant financial protection, but consider how these limits apply to your specific situation.
Medicare Advantage Plans generally require copayments for services, which can vary by plan. This contrasts with Original Medicare, which uses coinsurance.
The difference in cost-sharing mechanisms means that your out-of-pocket expenses can fluctuate based on the services you use and the plan you choose. The cost of these services varies depending on the specific plan.
Costs for Medicare Advantage Plans can differ significantly based on individual health needs and the services utilized. Consider not only the premiums and deductibles but also the potential copays and out-of-pocket limits.
By evaluating these factors, you can choose an affordable Medicare Advantage Plan that aligns with your financial and healthcare needs.
Provider Networks and Access
The accessibility and breadth of provider networks are critical considerations when choosing a Medicare Advantage Plan and MA plans.
Major insurers like Humana and Aetna are increasingly focusing on Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs), which typically provide more limited provider access to providers compared to Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs). While HMOs can offer cost savings, the trade-off is often a more restricted network of doctors and hospitals.
If you value broad access to a wide range of providers, PPO plans may be more suitable. However, make sure your preferred healthcare providers are included in the plan’s network before making a switch. This step ensures that you can continue seeing your trusted doctors without incurring additional out-of-network provider costs.
Ultimately, the choice between HMO and PPO plans depends on your healthcare needs and preferences. Understanding the implications of provider networks and access helps you choose a plan that offers the right balance of cost and convenience.
Compare plans and enroll online
Special Needs Plans (SNPs)
Special Needs Plans (SNPs) are tailored for individuals with specific health needs, providing targeted benefits and services. Aetna offers SNPs designed for those with chronic illnesses and individuals eligible for both Medicare and Medicaid.
These plans require eligibility based on having Medicare Parts A and B and meeting specific criteria related to chronic conditions or residency in care facilities.
Humana also provides SNPs, which include coverage for individuals with disabilities, chronic conditions, or those residing in long-term care facilities. These plans offer comprehensive benefits, encompassing standard Medicare Parts A and B coverage along with specialized services suited to the needs of their members.
For seniors with specific health needs, SNPs can offer a more tailored and beneficial healthcare experience. Knowing the eligibility requirements and the specific services covered by these plans can help you determine if an SNP is the right choice for you.
Customer Satisfaction and Member Experience
Customer satisfaction and member experience are crucial factors when evaluating Medicare Advantage Plans. Aetna is known for having the highest star ratings among Medicare Advantage providers in many states, indicating strong member satisfaction.
However, despite these high ratings, Aetna has received lower customer satisfaction scores in some markets.
Humana, on the other hand, scored 640 in Florida according to the J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Medicare Advantage Study, while Kaiser Permanente received the highest score of 675 in California.
This study also highlighted that high-performing plans achieve significantly higher digital satisfaction scores, which can greatly enhance member trust and overall experience, showcasing a strong performance. For example, these scores can influence consumer choices when selecting a plan.
Digital tools and organized services play a significant role in member satisfaction. When making a comparison of plans, consider the quality of customer service and the accuracy of digital resources, which can make managing your healthcare more convenient and efficient.
Prescription Drug Coverage (Part D)
Prescription drug coverage is a critical component of Medicare Advantage Plans. In 2025, the average monthly premium for Medicare Part D is projected to be $46.50, with an annual deductible not exceeding $590. These costs are important to consider when evaluating your overall healthcare expenses.
Humana offers $0-premium Medicare Part D plans in more than half of U.S. states, featuring numerous $0-copay and $0-deductible options. Their Value Rx plan includes multiple drug tiers where members can incur no out-of-pocket costs.
In contrast, Aetna’s SilverScript Choice plan does not provide $0-deductible options and has a single, less competitive plan offering.
When selecting a plan, consider the prescription drug coverage and the associated costs. Evaluating these factors will guide you in choosing a plan that provides necessary medication coverage without exceeding your budget.
Open Enrollment Tips
Open enrollment is a critical period for evaluating and selecting the best Medicare Advantage Plan. Consider additional benefits such as:
- Dental
- Vision
- Hearing
- Fitness programs
- Transportation
- In-home support
These benefits are not covered by Original Medicare but are offered by Humana and Aetna. Programs like SilverSneakers, included in the plans offered by both providers, can enhance your overall well-being.
Plans must disclose any changes in coverage or benefits during the annual enrollment period to ensure enrollees are fully informed. Also, understanding your rights to appeal decisions regarding cover and services is crucial. By keeping these tips in mind, you can make a well-informed decision during open enrollment.
Important Disclosures
Medicare Advantage organizations must offer a customer service contact number for enrollees seeking assistance regarding their plans. This ensures that you have access to support and can get answers to any questions you may have about your coverage.
Summary
In summary, both Humana and Aetna offer compelling Medicare Advantage Plans with unique benefits and extensive coverage. Humana’s broad reach and Part B Giveback provide significant value, while Aetna’s high star ratings and additional wellness benefits make it a strong contender. When choosing a plan, consider the coverage differences, pricing, provider networks, special needs plans, customer satisfaction, and prescription drug coverage to find the best fit for your needs.
Making an informed decision during open enrollment can significantly impact your healthcare experience and financial well-being. By understanding the key differences and advantages of Humana and Aetna Medicare Advantage Plans, you can select the plan that best aligns with your health and financial goals.
Frequently Asked Questions
→ Why is Aetna canceling Medicare Advantage plans?
Aetna is canceling Medicare Advantage plans primarily due to rising medical costs and reduced government payments, similar to trends seen with other major insurers in the market. This decision reflects broader changes in the healthcare landscape impacting Medicare offerings.
→ What unique benefit does Humana offer with its Medicare Advantage Plans?
Humana offers a unique benefit with its Medicare Advantage Plans by providing the Part B Giveback, which reimburses a portion of the member’s Medicare Part B premiums. This feature can help reduce overall healthcare costs for members.
→ How do Aetna’s Medicare Advantage Plans stand out?
Aetna’s Medicare Advantage Plans stand out due to their inclusion of comprehensive vision coverage, wellness programs, and meal delivery services, enhancing overall member support and care.
→ What are the out-of-pocket limits for Medicare Advantage Plans in 2025?
The out-of-pocket limits for Medicare Advantage Plans in 2025 are set at $9,350 for in-network care and $14,000 for combined in-network and out-of-network services. It’s important to be aware of these limits when considering your healthcare options.
→ What should I consider about provider networks when choosing a Medicare Advantage Plan?
When choosing a Medicare Advantage Plan, ensure that your preferred healthcare providers are included in the plan’s network to avoid unexpected out-of-pocket costs. This can significantly impact your overall healthcare experience.
Have Questions?
Speak with a licensed insurance agent
1-833-641-4938
TTY users 711
Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET
ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company
Find & Compare Plans Online
Russell Noga is the CEO of ZRN Health & Financial Services, and head content editor of several Medicare insurance online publications. He has over 15 years of experience as a licensed Medicare insurance broker helping Medicare beneficiaries learn about Medicare, Medicare Advantage Plans, Medigap insurance, and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans.