Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-833-641-4938

TTY user 711 Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Aflac Medicare Supplement Reviews 2027: Who Issues the Policy, Complaints and Real Price Gaps

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 4, 2026

Aflac Medicare Supplement reviews are weak on price and service: NerdWallet’s August 2026 review rates it 2.5 out of 5, citing complaints 138% above the Medigap average and premiums about 31% above the cheapest Plan G it found. The policies are issued by Tier One Insurance Company, an Aflac subsidiary, not by the A+ rated Aflac companies behind its workplace coverage.

2027 by the Numbers

2.5 / 5

NerdWallet review score, Aug. 1, 2026

138%

more complaints than the Medigap average, 2023-2025 NAIC data

14.8%

average base premium increase from 2025 to 2026 (NerdWallet)

42

states where Aflac sells Medicare Supplement plans

Aflac is best known for workplace cancer and accident coverage, and that reputation carries a lot of trust. Its Medicare Supplement line is newer. Aflac began selling it directly to consumers in August 2022, offering Plans A, F, G and N.

That short history means reviews are still building. This page separates the strong Aflac brand from the specific company that issues the Medigap policy, then checks the price and complaint record. For the plan lineup itself, see our Aflac Medicare Supplement plans for 2027.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Medigap is issued by Tier One Insurance Company of Omaha, an Aflac subsidiary

✔

Tier One does not appear in AM Best’s 2025 Aflac rating release

✔

Complaint rate was the second worst among companies NerdWallet reviewed

✔

Household discount of about 10%, and a spouse is not required

Compare plans and enroll online

The Company Behind the Aflac Name

When Aflac launched its Medicare Supplement in 2022, it named Tier One Insurance Company as the insurer and Aetna Life Insurance Company as the administrator. That detail matters, because the ratings people associate with Aflac belong to other companies in the family.

Role Company What we could confirm
Medigap insurer Tier One Insurance Company, Omaha, NE (NAIC 92908) Aflac subsidiary; Weiss Ratings C+ as of Nov. 2025
Administrator at launch Aetna Life Insurance Company Named in Aflac’s 2022 launch announcement
Main U.S. Aflac insurer American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus AM Best A+ (Superior), affirmed Sept. 2025
Other rated U.S. units Continental American Insurance Co.; American Family Life Assurance Co. of New York AM Best A+ (Superior), affirmed Sept. 2025

Sources: Aflac launch release (Aug. 4, 2022), AM Best release (Sept. 5, 2025), Weiss Ratings. Tier One was not among the companies listed in AM Best’s release, and we found no separate AM Best rating for it.

Read the fine print: Ads and agents may quote Aflac’s A+ rating. That grade applies to the companies named in AM Best’s release, not to Tier One. Ask which company’s rating is being cited.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-833-641-4938

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Aflac Medigap at a Glance

A, F, G, N

Plan letters sold, plus Wisconsin’s own standardized plans

About 10%

household discount in all three cities NerdWallet priced

74.3%

share of premium paid as benefits vs. 84.5% average

None

extra perks publicized for Aflac Medigap policies

Plan F is only open to people who were eligible for Medicare before 2020. Most new buyers choose between Plan G and Plan N, which we cover on our Aflac Plan G and Aflac Plan N pages.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-833-641-4938TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Complaints: What 138% Above Average Means

NAIC complaint data compares how many complaints a company receives against what would be expected for its share of the market. Using 2023-2025 figures, NerdWallet found Aflac’s Medigap complaints ran 138% above the average for all Medigap companies, the second-worst rate among the carriers it reviewed.

Putting the figure in context

✔

The ratio adjusts for company size, so a small book of business does not explain it away

✔

Complaint counts reflect billing, service and delays as well as claim issues

✔

The figure covers three years, so it is not a one-time spike

✔

You can check later years for Tier One Insurance Company in the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search

Aflac’s general ConsumerAffairs reviews mostly concern its workplace policies, so they say little about Medigap. The NAIC data is the more useful measure here because it is tied to the Medicare Supplement line.

Price Gaps in Three Cities, Turned Into Yearly Dollars

NerdWallet priced Aflac against the cheapest company it reviewed in each city. We converted the monthly gap into a yearly cost so the difference is easier to weigh.

City and plan Aflac Cheapest company checked Extra cost per year
Los Angeles, Plan G $267/mo $191/mo $912
Atlanta, Plan G $181/mo $140/mo $492
Dallas, Plan G $170/mo $138/mo $384
Los Angeles, Plan N $203/mo $146/mo $684
Atlanta, Plan N $122/mo $102/mo $240
Dallas, Plan N $116/mo $93/mo $276

Monthly prices from NerdWallet (Aug. 2026), with household discounts. Yearly differences computed by CMAP. Your own quote will differ by age, ZIP code and health.

Because every Plan G pays the same benefits by law, that extra cost buys no extra coverage. Our guide to the lowest-price Medicare Supplement Plan G shows how to find the cheaper end of your local market.

The 2026 Rate Jump and the Low Payout Ratio

Two other numbers stand out in recent reviews. Base premiums rose an average of 14.8% from 2025 to 2026, higher than average. And in the latest NAIC data, Aflac paid out about 74.3% of Medigap premium as member benefits, well under the 84.5% average.

Measure Aflac All-company average
Benefits paid per $100 of premium $74.30 $84.50
A $150 monthly premium after a 14.8% increase $172.20 n/a

CMAP calculations using NerdWallet-reported NAIC loss ratios and the 2025-2026 average base rate change. The $150 premium is a hypothetical example.

Licensed agent’s view: A low payout ratio on a young block of policies is common, since new enrollees are often healthier. Ratios usually rise as a block ages, which is one reason rate increases tend to continue over time.

Compare plans and enroll online

Where Aflac Sells and How the Discount Works

Not sold in

✔

Alaska, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maine

✔

Massachusetts, Minnesota, New York

✔

Washington state and Washington, D.C.

✔

Sold in the other 42 states, with plans varying by state

Household discount rules

✔

About 10% in NerdWallet’s sampled cities

✔

Qualify by living with a spouse

✔

Or by living with one to three other adults, in most states

✔

Spouse does not need to buy an Aflac policy in roommate-style states

Aflac Medigap is sold through partner agencies and directly through Aflac’s website. If you live in one of the excluded states, you will need another carrier.

When an Aflac Medigap Quote Can Still Make Sense

1

Your ZIP prices lower City samples are not your ZIP code. If your Aflac quote beats others after the discount, price is what matters most.

2

You value the brand relationship Some people already hold Aflac policies and prefer one company. Weigh that against the complaint record.

3

You compared rate history Ask for Tier One’s recent increases in your state, given the 14.8% average jump.

4

You checked the rating cited Make sure you know Tier One is the insurer, not the A+ rated Aflac companies.

For a model of how a more established carrier reads on these same measures, compare this review with our Cigna Medicare Supplement reviews.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Aflac’s Medigap line trades on a trusted name, but the policy comes from Tier One Insurance Company, and its review record shows above-average complaints, fast increases and prices well above the cheapest options. Get a quote only as one of several, and compare it against at least two longer-established carriers.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Who issues Aflac Medicare Supplement insurance?

Tier One Insurance Company, an Aflac subsidiary based in Omaha, Nebraska, issues the policies. At launch in 2022, Aetna Life Insurance Company was named as the administrator.

➤ Does Aflac Medicare Supplement have an A+ rating?

The A+ (Superior) grade AM Best affirmed in September 2025 applies to Aflac units such as American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus. Tier One Insurance Company was not listed in that release, and Weiss Ratings gave it a C+ as of November 2025.

➤ Why does Aflac Medigap get low reviews?

NerdWallet’s August 2026 review cites complaints 138% above the Medigap average, Plan G prices about 31% above the cheapest company it found and a 14.8% average base rate increase from 2025 to 2026.

➤ How long has Aflac sold Medicare Supplement plans?

Aflac announced its consumer Medicare Supplement product in August 2022, starting with Plans A, F, G and N. That makes it one of the newer Medigap brands.

➤ What states does Aflac Medicare Supplement cover?

It is sold in 42 states. It is not offered in Alaska, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New York, Washington state or Washington, D.C.

➤ Does Aflac offer a Medigap household discount?

Yes, about 10% in the cities NerdWallet sampled. In most states you can qualify by living with a spouse or with one to three other adults.

➤ What share of premiums does Aflac pay out in Medigap benefits?

About 74.3% in the latest NAIC figures cited by NerdWallet, compared with an 84.5% average. That works out to about $74 of every $100 going to claims.

➤ Are there extra perks with Aflac Medicare Supplement?

NerdWallet found no extra perks offered or publicized for Aflac’s Medigap policies. Other carriers sometimes add hearing, fitness or vision discounts.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-833-641-4938

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-833-641-4938TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company

Russell Noga, licensed insurance agent
( Medicare Expert )

Russell Noga is the CEO of ZRN Health & Financial Services, and head content editor of several Medicare insurance online publications. He has over 15 years of experience as a licensed Medicare insurance broker helping Medicare beneficiaries learn about Medicare, Medicare Advantage Plans, Medigap insurance, and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans.